IU Technology Architecture Lodge
Random and not so random thoughts from Raymond Yee, primarily on the scholarly and educational use of the Web, libraries, educational technology, and information management

 
Home

Print friendly version

Scholar's Box Essay Series

Current Projects

Presentations and Papers

Work on Educational Technology Interop

RY's wiki

RY's personal blog

About This Site

About Raymond Yee

Interactive University

Contact RY

My blogroll

RSS 2.0 feed for this site

 
 

Author:   Raymond Yee  
Posted: 7/12/2002; 7:44:33 AM
Topic: Is typing in conflict with lightweight markup?
Msg #: 544 (top msg in thread)
Prev/Next: 543/545
Reads: 2358

Is typing in conflict with lightweight markup? #

From Simon St. Laurent:

The W3C has already poisoned markup substantially with W3C XML Schema's various notions of type.  While XQuery has taken a few steps to separate itself from the PSVI, its own notions of type substantially complicate XQuery and have infected XSLT 2.0 and XPath 2.0.

The PSVI is just one especially nasty aspect of the problems created by retrofitting notions of type which come from object-oriented and relational systems (conflicting notions, at that) onto markup.  I expect the inconsistencies and complications of this decision to take a heavier toll on XML and the W3C than namespace and URI issues have taken in the past.

The W3C needs to think seriously about what it wants from markup.  I think  the W3C has lost sight of the promise XML originally had for the Web, as a lightweight format for loosely-coupling information producers and consumers.  Instead, recent efforts seem to be aimed at recreating CORBA or DCOM, a style of technology I thought the Web had pretty much shown up over the last decade.

These seem like fundamentally architectural issues to me, needing some serious discussion with a heavy dose of courage.


 
Posted by Raymond Yee on 7/12/02; 7:44:38 AM
from the Web Technology dept.

Discuss




Last update: Friday, July 12, 2002 at 7:45:14 AM.

This site is using the Vanilla Manila 1999 theme.
The opinions or statements expressed herein should not be taken as a position of or endorsement by the University of California, Berkeley. Nor should the opinions or statements expressed herein be taken as a position of or endorsement of the University of California, Berkeley. Links on these pages to commercial sites do not represent endorsement by the University of California or its affiliates.