IU Technology Architecture Lodge
Random and not so random thoughts from Raymond Yee, primarily on the scholarly and educational use of the Web, libraries, educational technology, and information management

 
Home

Print friendly version

Scholar's Box Essay Series

Current Projects

Presentations and Papers

Work on Educational Technology Interop

RY's wiki

RY's personal blog

About This Site

About Raymond Yee

Interactive University

Contact RY

My blogroll

RSS 2.0 feed for this site

 
 

Author:   Raymond Yee  
Posted: 5/21/2003; 11:37:30 PM
Topic: Jim Holt is a funny writer
Msg #: 804 (top msg in thread)
Prev/Next: 803/805
Reads: 3844

Jim Holt is a funny writer #

Jim Holt is an elegant and entertaining writer on all things mathematical and scientific.  Let me supply some quotes from an essay he wrote in The New York Review on the four color theorem.  (Unfortunately, the online article is available only to archive subscribers):

Mathematicians, it should be noted, were slow to warm to computers. Traditionally, from Pythagoras on, they have relied on pure hard thought to gain knowledge of new truths. It used to be said that a mathematics department was the second cheapest for a university to fund, because its members required only pencils, paper, and wastebaskets. (The cheapest would be the philosophers, because they don't need the wastebaskets.) As late as 1986, a mathematician at Stanford boasted that his department had fewer computers than any other, including French literature

[....]

The four-color breakthrough marked a shift in mathematical practice. Since then, several other conjectures have been resolved with the aid of computers (notably, in 1988, the nonexistence of a projective plane of order ten). Meanwhile, mathematicians have tidied up the Haken-Appel argument so that the computer part is much shorter, and some still hope that a traditional, elegant, and illuminating proof of the four-color theorem will someday be found. It was the desire for illumination, after all, that motivated so many to work on the problem, even to devote their lives to it, during its long history. (One mathematician had his bride color maps on their honeymoon.)


 
Posted by Raymond Yee on 5/21/03; 11:37:33 PM
from the Unclassified dept.

Discuss




Last update: Wednesday, May 21, 2003 at 11:37:30 PM.

This site is using the Vanilla Manila 1999 theme.
The opinions or statements expressed herein should not be taken as a position of or endorsement by the University of California, Berkeley. Nor should the opinions or statements expressed herein be taken as a position of or endorsement of the University of California, Berkeley. Links on these pages to commercial sites do not represent endorsement by the University of California or its affiliates.